Bagelicious East Meadow

Nick Amblo

Worst place I’ve been to. Went here three times, had my order made wrong or not made at all three times. I would recommend any other deli or bagel store other than this one. Horrible service.

Matt Carter

I am surprised at the number of negative reviews that Bagelicious has received as of late. As an out-of-stater, I was first introduced to Bagelicious 11 years ago. I didn't know I liked bagels until I was introduced to the Long Island bagel, and Bagelicious bagels are at the top of the bagel food chain. Anyone who says otherwise is an idiot. My New England friends all request that I bring them Bagelicious every time I visit Long Island (which is several times a year). We keep them in the freezer (not as good as fresh, but better than anything you can find locally). Their staff is great, their food is great, so maybe if you are complaining about their food or their service, YOU are the problem. because I have never had any issues in there with ANYTHING at Bagelicious. I hope they keep on doing what they've been doing because this place is fantastic. I'm a Rhode Islander, but I LOOOVE East Meadow and I love Bagelicious. Don't change anything, and don't listen to the negative reviews. Bagelicious in East Meadow rules.

S G

Not as good as it used to be. Former owners John and John, took pride in the quality of food and staff. It’s just okay, now. Biggest turn off is staff Not wearing masks or masks sitting on their chins. They charge 4% to use a debit card. This should be illegal. I’ll go elsewhere.

Jon Galarza

This is a great spot to get a bagel in East Meadow hands down. It has always been my go to for quick breakfast for nearly 20 years. However, I koved out of New York and went back to visit family. I stopped in for breakfast and was quite surprised. The place was not packed as it used to be and the quality was significantly different. I was surprised at how high the prices were yet the quality of the food went down. I paid $28 for 3 bagles!!! It was a pretty big let down for something I was craving for a while. If you're looking for a regular bagel with cream cheese go for it but anything else, don't bother.