I Love NY Pizza

Honey Macewan

I ordered a pizza asking them to make sure the cheese went as close to the edge as they could. It was a specialty pizza for $19.50. When I got it home, they did the opposite. Each slice had about 3" of cheese and topping, and the crust was about 3"... which ended up in the trash. Will never order from them again. Had I known, I def wouldn't have given them a $5 tip!!

Susan Kellogg

I have bought our pizza there for a long time, but lately been a mistake every time I order but I just let it go because these are tough times for many businesses. But this time was burnt and wrong sauce. The man on phone said he could replace if I wanted to drive back to get another one but I couldn’t do that. That was really only option, not good business practice. I realize they are very popular but really?

Binit Patel

One of the best pizzas in the region. Love the crunchy base and huge slices!

Bill McCoy

We usually eat there and even though it's always very busy service is great! Those girls work their butts off! Food is awesome as well. We absolutely love their chicken wings. Calzones and pizza are also wonderful. I can't wait to try the chef salad next!