A Slice of Brooklyn - New Holland

Carly K.

We just tried this place for the first time tonight. When we called the lady told us 45 minutes for 2 large pizzas. While we thought that was alittle long of a time we said OK. Well when we got it home it was about 10 minutes overcooked. The crust was hard, and burnt on both pizzas. We enjoyed the sauce and cheese part but the crust was not enjoyable, it almost was like a cracker texture. Probably won't be our go to pizza place.

Autumn Labanoski

The grandma pizza is delicious and the staff is always so nice and helpful!

K

Despite the fact that they still don't allow patrons in their lobby (very strange) the pizza was pretty yummy! But again, it was a pain to order, literally had to stand at the drive through window in the cold (it was also sprinkling) for the food. Also no fountain drinks, only bottles. So dislike for the overall experience of this place.

Zane K

DoorDash estimated 25 minutes so gave it a try. Almost 45 minutes later the order wasn’t updated and called with a guy telling me I was next. 30 minutes later called again and was told the same. Cancelled order. Prior experiences have been similar. Food is not great but it’s close. Previously warned by locals to avoid it. 3rd strike for us.