Mark's Pizzeria

Richard McCulloch

We have been searching for the best New York pizza, and we found it! The sauce is amazing and the staff is super friendly. I love the thick, crispy crust. This is the best pizza ever!

My Life

06/2021 - Love it most of the time last visit was excellent. Delivery is usually fast ($5 fee, up a dollar since last time I ordered) and pickup is usually ready within 20 minutes. Indoor and outdoor seating options. Building was remodeled not that many years back due to a fire so everything is super new. 2019 - I literally have a love-hate relationship with this place most of the time 😁. I've been ordering from this specific store since I was a child and my parents used to place the orders. They are by far my favorite pizza place. However, there were at least three times that I can count where I had to cut them off for a while. The first time I stopped ordering from them for almost 15 years because I was so upset. Within the last three or four years I have decided to try them again and have only had to cut them off twice due to customer service issues. Once there was a refusal of delivery before they were closed another time with an issue with toppings and a refusal to fix it. All in all the pizza is just too good to order from any place else like that. And other marks pizzas just don't seem to taste the same as the one in palmyra.

Victor Domine

Friendly staff, clean restaurant, great breadsticks and pizza. Was pleasantly surprised at just how good it was. This location was also interesting because they incorporated the areas rich history into the photography, newspaper articles, and sponsored groups celebrated on their walls demonstrating strong community ties. Will definitely be back next time I'm in the area.

Terry Barber

Outstanding service and great pizza! I am saving some for tomorrow lunch! The White sauce and The Red Sauce was secretly placed in different places of my pizza. It was super awesome as it made every bite different from the other. The breadsticks and pizza crust was soft and baked fresh. The staff were very enthusiastic and ready to serve. Great northeast pizza experience👍