Carl's Pizza Kitchen

emily

This is our favorite pizza place in Webster. If you’re looking for a delicious thin crust NY style pizza—look no further! We’ve been here several times and the pizza has been perfect every single time. I can tell the owners really care about what they do! My father passed away recently and this was his favorite place too. We just ordered a pizza from here tonight to share and although it was weird to eat it without him, it was just as delicious as usual!

Susan Gurak

The pizza was delivered quickly and was hot. We loved it! Great price for a huge pizza! We will definitely order from Carls again!!!!!

Michelle Peck

Dough is vey tough and the crust is almost impossible to chew. The dough has a lot of corn meal in it too. Flavors are bland. We tried one red and one garlic. It was delivered 1hr10min after ordered and was cold. Not a fan. The search for decent pizza in Webster continues.

Roy Dillenbeck

So my girlfriend and I decided to check this joint out. First, let me say the owner was very friendly. Second, I ordered a large pie. Well, let me just say I was NOT expecting just how large it was. I will say the pizza was very good. But what really impressed me the most is something that pizza shops don't do anymore. When I went to pick it up, the owner opened the box to show me the pie. That tells me personally that he cares about his products that he makes and wants the customer to be happy as well. Well done sir, well done indeed. I will definitely return and tell my friends and neighbors too. Carl's Pizza Kitchen may be small, but they serve big taste. Just to give you an idea how large it was, I placed a standard dinner plate next to it. Review update 11/7/21 I posted the prior review 6 months earlier. I meant to post this before, but I forgot too. If you like white pizza then you must check out this joint. As always, great service, great pizza and wings among other items on Carl's menu. The second photo a medium white pizza.